Here's Where the 'American Pie' Stars Are Today

Stifler's Mom's Biggest Fan, Paul Finch, Played By Eddie Kaye Thomas

Stifler and Finch are the ultimate odd couple, clashing constantly due to their stark differences in personality and outlook. While Finch may be a teenager, he carries himself like an old soul, adding a quirky charm to his character. When he meets his nemesis’ mother, Finch falls head over heels, creating one of the film’s most hilarious storylines. As their unlikely romance unfolds, Finch reveals a softer, more endearing side that makes you cheer for him

Eddie Kaye Thomas, who plays Finch, started his acting career at just ten years old in the Brooklyn Shakespeare Company’s production of Richard III. Today, he’s known for his work on TV shows like The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel and his voice acting role in American Dad. His versatile talent brings depth to Finch, making the character both relatable and memorable. Who wouldn’t root for a guy with such a unique mix of awkwardness and charm? This dynamic duo’s antics and Finch’s unexpected love story keep audiences laughing and invested from start to finish.